All Ohio
Dylan Hanlon 3rd team 1991, 1st team 1992
Andrew Cerniglia 3rd team 1993
David Hradek 3rd team 2001, 2002
Jeremy Irias 3rd team 2008
All District
Dylan Hanlon 1991, 1992
Andrew Cerniglia 1993
Charles Cerniglia 1996
John Rice 2000
David Hradek 2001, 2002
Lawrence Cerniglia 2003
Kyle Seigley 2004
Ryan Troyer 2nd Team 2005, 2006
Jeff Rice 1st Team 2006
Jeremy Irias 2007 and 2008
All Wayne-Holmes Coaches Association
Andrew Cerniglia 1991,1992,1993
Dylan Hanlon 1991, 1992 (Wayne Holmes Player of Year)
Eric Lingenfelter 1991, 1992
Tom Obrst 1991 second team
Brent Swartzentruber 1991 second team
Troy Crilow 1991, 1992 second team
Mike Crilow 1993
Josh Crilow 1994 first team, 1995 second team
Charles Cerniglia 1995 second team, 1996 first team
Mark Wimer 1996 first team
David Durstine 1996 second team
Jeremy Summers 1996 second team
John Summers 1997 first team
John Barker 1997 second team
Mike Rowe 1997 second team
John Summers 1997, 1998 first team
Dan Buss 1998 second team
Dustin Yoder 1998 second team
John Rice 1999 second team 2000 first team
Justin Smith 1999 second team 2000 first team
Matt Keener 2000 second team
Nate Chrapowicki 2000, 2001 second team
David Hradek 2001 first team 2002 (Player of the Year)
Ryan Miller 2002 second team
Lawrence Cerniglia 2003
Kyle Seigley 2004
Kyle Moore 2004 second tea
Ryan Troyer 2005 second team
Kirk Brenner 2005 second team
Jeff Rice 2nd team 2006
Kirk Brenner 2008
Jeremy Irias 2009
Tim Kurtz 2008
Kevin Holcombe 2008
All Wayne County Athletic League
John Summers 1997 1998 1st team
John Barker 1997 1st team
Adam Bracken 1997 2nd team
Ty Hostetler 1997 2nd team
Dan Buss 1998 1st team
Dustin Yoder 1998 2nd team
Matt Gilbert 1998 2nd team
John Rice 1999, 2000 1st team
Mike Barker 1999 1st team
Justin Smith 1999 2nd team 2000 1st team
Nate Chrapowicki 2000 2nd team 2001 1st team
Willie Parrot 2001 2nd team
Jared Durstine 2001 2nd team
David Hradek 2000 2nd team 2001 1st team 2002 1st team (WCAL Player of the Year)
Ryan Miller 2002 1st team
Lawrence Cerniglia 2002 2003 1st team
Ryan Davies 2002 2nd team
Brian Still 2002 2nd team
Kyle Seigley 2003 second team 2004 1st team
Kyle Moore 2004 Goalkeeper of the Year
Mike Skelly 1st team 2004
Mark Skelly 2nd team 2004
Brian Parrto 2nd team 2004
Scott Crilow 1st team 2005
Kirk Brenner 1st team 2005J
Jermey Irias 2nd team 2005
Ryan Troer 2nd team 2005
Ryan Troyer 1st Team 2006
Jeff Rice 1st Team 2006
Jeff Hradek 2nd team 2006
Kirk Brenner 2nd team 2006 1st team 2007
Ryan Troyer Goalkeeper of the Year 2007
Tim Kurtz 2008 Player of the Year
Jeremy Irias 1st team 2007, 2008
Kevin Holcombe 1st team 2008 2nd team 2007
Academic All Ohio
Ellen Cerniglia 1994
Becca Orr 1995
Charles Cerniglia 1996
Mark Wimer 1996
Adam Bracken 1997
Dan Buss 1998
Matt Gilbert 1999
John Rice 2000
David Hradek 2002
Jimmy Croskey 2003
Tim Geiser 2005
Jeff Rice 2006